Death Penalty Information
- IPDC
- Current: Death Penalty Information
In Indiana, the death penalty is never automatic — prosecutors have discretion to decide whether to seek it. It is available only for murder cases where at least one of 18 specific aggravating circumstances can be proven.
If a defendant is convicted of murder, the trial moves to a separate penalty phase where the jury must unanimously agree that the aggravating circumstances outweigh any mitigating factors. If the jury cannot reach a unanimous sentencing decision, the judge determines the sentence.
Every death sentence is automatically reviewed by the Indiana Supreme Court on direct appeal, and the defendant may also pursue additional state and federal reviews.
If carried out, executions are performed by lethal injection, though ongoing issues with drug sourcing and secrecy remain.
County Filed In | Defendant | Date Death Penalty Filed | Current Status |
---|---|---|---|
Marion | John Adams | 2/24/2000 | Pending trial. Found incompetent to stand trial on October 2000 |
Madison | Carl Boards II | 08/17/2022 | Pending trial |
Marion | Orlando Mitchell | 07/13/2023 | Pending trial |
Hendricks | Dalonny Rodgers | 07/29/24 | Pending trial |
Sentenced | Inmate | Current Status |
---|---|---|
1993 | Eric D. Holmes | Cert. from Federal Habeas denial denied. |
2000 | Michael Dean Overstreet | Found incompetent to be executed in 2014. AG did not appeal. |
2007 | Roy Ward | AG has requested an execution date. |
2013 | Kevin Isom | Pending Federal Habeas Corpus Review |
2013 | Jeffrey Weisheit | Pending Federal Habeas Corpus Review |
2013 & 2014 | William Clyde Gibson III | Pending Federal Habeas Corpus Review |

Indiana Public Defender Council
Copyright © 2025 State of Indiana - All rights reserved.