Mammals
- Allegheny Woodrat
- Badger
- Beaver
- Black Bear
- Bobcat
- Chipmunk
- Cottontail Rabbit
- Coyote
- Eastern Mole
- Fox Squirrel
- Gray Fox
- Gray Squirrel
- Gray Wolf
- Groundhog (Woodchuck)
- Feral / Wild Hog
- Indiana Bat
- Mink
- Mountain Lion
- Muskrat
- Nine-Banded Armadillo
- Opossum
- Raccoon
- Red Fox
- River Otter
- Striped Skunk
- Weasels
- White-Tailed Deer
Birds
- Bald Eagle
- Barn Owl
- Bobwhite Quail
- Canada Goose
- Cardinal
- Loggerhead Shrike
- Osprey
- Peregrine Falcon
- Ruffed Grouse
- Sandhill Crane
- Whooping Crane
- Wild Turkey
Fish
Reptiles and amphibians
- Alligator Snapping Turtle
- American Toad
- Blanding's Turtle
- Bullfrog
- Cope's Gray Treefrog and Eastern Gray Treefrog
- Common Gartersnake
- Common Watersnake
- Crawfish Frog
- Eastern Box Turtle
- Eastern Hog-nosed Snake
- Eastern Spadefoot Toad
- Fowler's Toad
- Gray Ratsnake
- Green Frog
- Green Salamander
- Green Treefrog
- Massasauga Rattlesnake
- Mediterranean Gecko
- Northern Cricket Frog
- Northern Leopard Frog
- Pickerel Frog
- Plain's Leopard Frog
- Snakes
- Southern Leopard Frog
- Spring Peeper
- Timber Rattlesnake
- Western Chorus Frog
- Wood Frog