Note: This message is displayed if (1) your browser is not standards-compliant or (2) you have you disabled CSS. Read our Policies for more information.
** = not elected, but served due to resignation or death of the governor
| Name | Term | Party | County |
| Jonathan Jennings (1787-1834) | Nov 7, 1816 - Dec 4, 1819 | Clark | |
| Ratliff Boon (1781-1844)** | Sept 12, 1822 - Dec 4, 1822 | Warrick | |
| William Hendricks (1782-1850) | Dec 4, 1822 - Feb 12, 1825 | Jefferson | |
| James Brown Ray (1794-1848) | Feb 12, 1825 - Dec 7, 1831 | Franklin | |
| Noah Noble (1794-1844) | Dec 7, 1831 - Dec 6, 1837 | W | Marion |
| David Wallace (1799-1859) | Dec 6, 1837 - Dec 9, 1840 | W | Fountain |
| Samuel Bigger (1802-1846) | Dec 9, 1840 - Dec 6, 1843 | W | Rush |
| James Whitcomb (1795-1852) | Dec 6, 1843 - Dec 26, 1848 | D | Monroe |
| Paris C. Dunning (1806-1884)** | Dec 26, 1848 - Dec 5, 1849 | D | Monroe |
| Joseph A. Wright (1810-1867) | Dec 5, 1849 - Jan 12, 1857 | D | Parke |
| Ashbel P. Willard (1820-1860) | Jan 12, 1857 - Oct 4, 1860 | D | Floyd |
| Abram A Hammond (1814-1874)** | Oct 4, 1860 - Jan 14, 1861 | D | Marion |
| Henry S. Lane (1811-1881) | Jan 14, 1861 - Jan 16, 1861 | R | Montgomery |
| Oliver P. Morton (1823-1877)** | Jan 16, 1861 - Jan 23, 1867 | R | Wayne |
| Conrad Baker (1817-1885)** | Jan 23, 1867 - Jan 13, 1873 | R | Vanderburgh |
| Thomas Hendricks (1819-1885) | Jan 13, 1873 - Jan 8, 1877 | D | Shelby |
| James D. Williams (1808-1880) | Jan 8, 1877 - Nov 20, 1880 | D | Knox |
| Isaac P. Gray (1828-1895)** | Nov 20, 1880 - Jan 10, 1881 | D | Randolph |
| Albert G. Porter (1824-1897) | Jan 10, 1881 - Jan 12, 1885 | R | Maron |
| Isaac P. Gray (1828-1895) | Jan 12, 1885 - Jan 14, 1889 | D | Randolph |
| Alvin P. Hovey (1821-1891) | Jan 14, 1889 - Nov 23, 1891 | R | Posey |
| Ira J. Chase (1834-1895)** | Nov 23, 1891 - Jan 9, 1893 | R | Hendricks |
| Claude Matthews (1845-1898) | Jan 9, 1893 - Jan 11, 1897 | D | Vermillion |
| James A. Mount (1843-1901) | Jan 11, 1897 - Jan 14, 1901 | R | Montgomery |
| Winfield T. Durbin (1847-1928) | Jan 14, 1901 - Jan 9 1905 | R | Madison |
| J. Frank Hanly (1863-1920) | Jan 9, 1905 - Jan 11, 1909 | R | Warren |
| Thomas R. Marshall (1854-1925) | Jan 11, 1909 - Jan 13, 1913 | D | Whitley |
| Samuel M. Ralston (1857-1925) | Jan 13, 1913 - Jan 8, 1917 | D | Boone |
| James P. Goodrich (1864-1940) | Jan 8, 1917 - Jan 10, 1921 | R | Randolph |
| Warren T. McCray (1865-1938) | Jan 10, 1921 - April 30, 1924 | R | Newton |
| Emmett F. Branch (1874-1932)** | April 30, 1924 - Jan 12, 1925 | R | Morgan |
| Edward L. Jackson (1873-1954) | Jan 12, 1925 - Jan 14,1929 | R | Marion |
| Harry G. Leslie (1878-1937) | Jan 14, 1929 - Jan 9, 1933 | R | Tippecanoe |
| Paul V. McNutt (1891-1955) | Jan 9, 1933 - Jan 11, 1937 | D | Monroe |
| M. Clifford Townsend (1884-1954) | Jan 11, 1937 - Jan 13, 1941 | D | Grant |
| Henry F. Schricker (1883-1966) | Jan 13, 1941 - Jan 8, 1945 | D | Starke |
| Ralph F. Gates (1893-1978) | Jan 8, 1945 - Jan 10, 1949 | R | Whitley |
| Henry F. Schricker (1883-1966) | Jan 13, 1949 - Jan 12, 1953 | D | Starke |
| George N. Craig (1909-1992) | Jan 12, 1953 - Jan 10, 1957 | R | Clay |
| Harold W. Handley (1909-1972) | Jan 14, 1957 - Jan 9, 1961 | R | La Porte |
| Matthew E Welsh (1912-1995) | Jan 9, 1961 - Jan 11, 1965 | D | Knox |
| Roger D. Branigin (1902-1975) | Jan 11, 1965 - Jan 13, 1969 | D | Tippecanoe |
| Edgar D. Whitcomb (1917- ) | Jan 13, 1969 - Jan 9, 1973 | R | Jackson |
| Otis R. Bowen (1918- ) | Jan 9, 1973 - Jan 12, 1981 | R | Marshall |
| Robert Orr (1917-2004) | Jan 12, 1981 - Jan 9, 1989 | R | Vanderburgh |
| Birch Evans "Evan" Bayh, III (1955-) | January 9, 1989 - January 13, 1997 | D | Marion |
| Frank L. O'Bannon (1930-2003) | January 13, 1997 - September 13, 2003 | D | Harrison |
| Joe Kernan (1946-) | September 13, 2003 - January 10, 2005 | D | Marion |
| Mitchell E. Daniels, Jr. (1949-) | January 10, 2005 - | D | Marion |