April, 2016: Comparing Air Quality Between States
Many people like to compare air quality between different areas of the country to determine who has the cleanest air . The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency recently added an interactive tool called AirCompare to its website to do just that. I tried using it to compare ozone levels between Indianapolis and New York City . Indianapolis was shown as having much worse air quality. This was puzzling. When I investigated closer, what was actually being compared was air quality in Marion County, Indiana versus Kings County, New York. Marion County, Indiana had a population of 934,243 in 2014 and had 5 ozone monitors. Kings County, New York had a population of 2,621,793 in 2014 and no ozone monitors. This caused me to wonder how many other similar counties had no ozone monitors, which led to the following analysis.
For each county or equivalent I determined the 2014 population and the land area in square miles. I also determined the 2011 emission rate of volatile organic compounds (VOC) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) from U.S. EPA’s National Emissions Inventory . Data for 2011 is the most recent data available. These two pollutants combine to form ozone. With this data I calculated the highest ten counties that did not have ozone monitors in 2014 based upon: population, population density, VOC emissions, VOC density, NOx emissions and NOx density. I set one further criteria. The area of the county, or equivalent, must be at least 50 square miles to remove small cities that have very small land areas that lead to large densities. Table 1 shows the counties based upon the 2014 population. Kings County, NY tops the list. The overall rank shows the rank among all counties including those that monitor ozone.
|Table 1: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on Population|
|Rank||County/State||2014 Population||Overall Rank|
|1||Kings County, NY||2,621,793||8|
|2||Nassau County, NY||1,358,627||28|
|3||Snohomish County, WA||759,583||81|
|4||Fort Bend County, TX||685,345||91|
|5||Jackson County, MO||683,191||92|
|6||Union County, NJ||552,939||118|
|7||Ramsey County, MN||532,655||124|
|8||Williamson County, TX||489,250||139|
|9||Virginia Beach city, VA||450,980||150|
|10||Burlington County, NJ||449,722||151|
While it is understood that U.S. EPA’s monitoring strategy does not require every single county in a Metropolitan Statistical Area to have an ozone monitor, shouldn’t the most populated counties in the nation have ozone monitors?
However, all counties are not the same size. So perhaps the better comparison is on population density (population divided by the land area in square miles). Table 2 shows this data. Kings County, NY is still number one.
|Table 2: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on Population Density|
|Rank||County/State||Population Density||Overall Rank|
|1||Kings County, NY||36,927||2|
|2||Union County, NJ||5,368||18|
|3||Nassau County, NY||4,734||20|
|4||Norfolk city, VA||4,545||22|
|5||Richmond city, VA||3,631||30|
|6||Ramsey County, MN||3,414||31|
|7||Newport News city, VA||2,691||45|
|8||Clayton County, GA||1,871||73|
|9||Virginia Beach city, VA||1,818||76|
|10||Howard County, MD||1,227||121|
Perhaps population is not the only parameter that should be used for monitor selection. Table 3 looks at VOC emissions by county to determine the counties with the highest VOC emissions that do not have ozone monitors.
|Table 3: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on VOC Emissions|
|Rank||County/State||Emissions (Tons Per Year [TPY])||Overall Rank|
|1||Southeast Fairbanks Borough, AK||194,258||1|
|2||Yukon-Koyukuk Borough, AK||186,548||2|
|3||Cameron Parish, LA||133,186||4|
|4||North Slope Borough, AK||126,177||5|
|5||Greenlee County, AZ||124,326||6|
|6||Apache County, AZ||105,123||11|
|7||Washington County, NY||67,191||21|
|8||Mountrail County, ND||57,572||26|
|9||Lemhi County, ID||54,766||27|
|10||Idaho County, ID||48,361||28|
Five of the six counties with the highest VOC emissions do not have ozone monitors. While some may argue that three are in Alaska, are we sure that given these levels of emissions and sunlight for 24 hours a day, that the new ozone standard would be met if monitors were there?
Perhaps we should be looking at VOC emission density since many of the counties included in Table 3 are large in size. Table 4 looks at this data.
|Table 4: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on VOC Emissions Density|
|Rank||County/State||VOC Emissions Density (TPY/sq mi)||Overall Rank|
|1||Kings County, NY||346.9||2|
|2||Union County, NJ||106.1||25|
|3||Norfolk County, VA||104.6||26|
|4||Ramsey County, MN||101.5||28|
|5||Cameron Parish, LA||101.4||29|
|6||Richmond city, VA||90.6||31|
|7||Nassau County, NY||86.4||34|
|8||Washington County, NY||80.5||36|
|9||Greenlee County, AZ||67.3||47|
|10||Newport News city, VA||66.2||50|
The list shifts significantly when switching to VOC density instead of VOC emissions. Kings County, NY pops up on top again.
The other pollutant that leads to ozone formation is nitrogen oxides (NOx). Table 5 shows the top ten counties with the most NOx emissions that do not have ozone monitors.
|Table 5: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on NOx Emissions|
|Rank||County/State||2011 NOx Emissions (TPY)||Overall Rank|
|1||North Slope Borough, AK||49,821||10|
|2||Plaquemine Parish, LA||37,944||24|
|3||York County, PA||33,393||42|
|4||Emmons County, ND||31,711||45|
|5||Millard County, UT||31,284||48|
|6||Jackson County, MO||28,255||59|
|7||Apache County, AZ||28,021||62|
|8||Miller County, GA||27,039||64|
|9||Monroe County, MI||25,682||68|
|10||Rogers County, OK||24,541||71|
Finally Table 6 shows the top ten counties that have the highest NOx emissions density but have no ozone monitors.
|Table 6: Top Ten Counties without Ozone Monitors Based on NOx Emissions Density|
|Rank||County/State||NOx Emissions Density (TPY/sq mi)||Overall Rank|
|1||Kings County, NY||267.6||5|
|2||Union County, NJ||132.2||15|
|3||Richmond city, VA||115.1||19|
|4||Montour County, PA||105.7||23|
|5||Norfolk city, VA||105.3||24|
|6||Ramsey County, MN||105.1||25|
|7||Miller County, GA||95.5||29|
|8||Nassau County, NY||83.4||34|
|9||Carroll County, KY||74.7||39|
|10||Clayton County, GA||73.7||41|
The point of these comparisons is that when comparing air quality between states, it is difficult to assess whether both states are adequately measuring ozone levels. If counties with large populations, large population densities, or large VOC or NOx emissions are not being monitored, comparisons may be less than accurate.
Comments on this article and/or any previous article can be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
- April 2016: Comparing Air Quality Between States
- December 2015: Ozone Levels in Indiana, A Success Story
- October 2015: Determining What Controls are Necessary for Lead in Muncie
- September 2015: Optimizing Power Plant Emissions
- September 2015: Air Quality Expectations
- August 2015: Sulfur Dioxide in Indiana
- June 2015: Don’t Shoot the Messenger (New Ozone Standard and Asthma)
- May 2015: Different Methodology and Different Grades
- April 2015: How We Know Indiana’s Air Quality Is Good
- February 2015: How Do You Rate a State’s Air Quality - Comparing Data
- January 2015: Indiana’s Air Quality and Manufacturing
- September 2014: U.S. EPA’s Proposed Clean Power Plan (Continued)
- August 2014: U.S. EPA’s Proposed Clean Power Plan
- July 2014: Progress in Air Quality Levels?
- May 2014: Want to Understand Air Quality in Your Area? Check Out IDEM’s Report
- May 2014: Environmental Halloween?
- April 2014: How Low Will They Go? (U.S. EPA's New Ozone Standard)
- April 2014: The States’ View of the Air (2014)
- March 2014: Is Indiana’s Air Quality Getting Worse?
- March 2014: How Should We Regulate Indiana’s Air?
- February 2014: Wintertime PM2.5 Events
- February 2014: The Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) and Air Quality
- January 2014: Air Modeling and AERMOD
- January 2014: The America’s Health Rankings Annual Report and Air Pollution in Indiana
- November 2013: CO2e and What It Means
- October 2013: The Percent of Hoosiers Breathing Clean Air
- October 2013: Carbon Dioxide (CO2) Emissions From Electric Utilities
- September 2013: The States View of Air 2013
- September 2013: Issues Related to Comments Received About "Air Quality 101" Articles
- August 2013: Air Quality Dispersion Modeling
- September 2013: American Lung Association Report, State of the Air
- August 2013: Air Permits, Part Two
- July 2013: Air Permits, Part One
- July 2013: How to Estimate Potential to Emit (PTE) for Air Permits
- June 2013: How Does Indiana’s Air Quality Compare to Other States?
- June 2013: Air Quality Action Day Advisory Program
- May 2013: The Status of Air Quality in Indiana
- May 2013: Office of Air Quality
- April 2013: Air Toxics
- April 2013: Ambient Monitoring in Indiana
- March 2013: Criteria Pollutants and National Ambient Air Quality Standards
- March 2013: Introduction