Here is the roll of Indiana Teachers of the Year. National finalists are marked with asterisks in 1978, 1994, 1996 and 2015:
- 2021 - All Indiana Teachers Honored as Teacher of the Year
- 2020 - Katheryn Pourcho - Danville Community School Corporation
- 2019 - Tamara Markey - Metropolitan School District of Lawrence Township
- 2018 - Jerome Flewelling - Crown Point Community School Corporation
- 2017 - Jitka Nelson - Logansport Community High School
- 2016 - Jean Russell - Haverhill Elementary School
- 2015 - *Kathy Nimmer - Harrison High School
- 2014 - Steven Perkins - North Central High School
- 2013 - Suzanne Whitton - Delaware Trail Elementary School, Brownsburg
- 2012 - Melanie Park - Riverview School, Huntington
- 2011 - Stacy McCormack - Penn Harris Madison School Corporation, Mishawaka
- 2010 - Byron Ernest - Lebanon High School, Lebanon
- 2009 - Tania Harman - Warren Primary Center, South Bend
- 2008 - Daniel Kuznik - Pike High School Freshman Center, Indianapolis
- 2007 - Anna Shults - Fall Creek Elementary School, Fishers
- 2006 - Louisa LaGrotto - Westlane Middle School, Indianapolis
- 2005 - Molly Seward - Snacks Crossing Elementary School, Indianapolis
- 2004 - Mark Weaver - Clay Junior High School, Carmel
- 2003 - Robert Pickett - Marion Elementary School, Sheridan
- 2002 - Terri L. Boutin - S. Ellen Jones Elementary School, New Albany
- 2001 - Kurran Strunk - Muessel Elementary School, South Bend
- 2000 - Kathy Politz - West Vigo Elementary School, Terre Haute
- 1999 - Larry Hurt - Ben Davis High School, Indianapolis
- 1998 - Kim Giesting - Connersville Senior High School, Connersville
- 1997 - Judy Fraps - Greenbriar Elementary School, Indianapolis
- 1996 - *Dan Durbin - Francis Joseph Reitz High School, Evansville
- 1995 - Katherine Stahl - Maywood Elementary School, Hammond
- 1994 - *Francis Mustapha - South Side High School, Fort Wayne
- 1993 - Diane Cutshall Hayes - Indian Meadows Elementary School, Fort Wayne
- 1992 - Michael Kaiser - Pine View Elementary School, New Albany
- 1991 - Darcia King-O'Blenis - Navarre Middle School, South Bend
- 1990 - Mary Kay Baker - Rise Learning Center, Indianapolis
- 1989 - Karen McKibbon - LaSalle High School, South Bend
- 1988 - Tony Willis - Jeffersonville High School, Jeffersonville
- 1987 - Bob Mulligan - John Glenn High School, Walkerton
- 1986 - Bernard Barcio - Carmel High School, Carmel
- 1985 - Paulette Cwidak - John Adams High School, South Bend
- 1984 - Glen Dillman - Carroll Junior High School, Flora
- 1983 - Victor Bardonner - Lawrence Central High School, Indianapolis
- 1982 - Sofia Rodriguez - Snider High School, Fort Wayne
- 1981 - Calvin Lee - Hoagland Elementary School, Hoagland
- 1980 - Daniel Rayschich - John Hinds Area Vocational School, Elwood
- 1979 - Robert Ciscell - South Decatur Junior-Senior High School, Greensburg
- 1978 - *Sue Talbot - University Elementary School, Bloomington
- 1977 - Oscar Underwood - Southwick Elementary School, Fort Wayne
- 1976 - Joyce McFadden - Dwight Eisenhower Elementary School, Crown Point
- 1975 - Barbara D. Moore - Western Elementary School, Russiaville
- 1974 - Charles Stephens - Joy Elementary School, Michigan City
- 1973 - Emaline Kleinknecht - Tekopel Elementary School, Evansville
- 1972 - Ruth Swank - Riverside Elementary School, Fort Wayne
- 1971 - Rudolph Holycross - Columbia City High School, Columbia City
- 1970 - Kay Mendenhall - Oliver Morton Elementary School, Winchester
- 1969 - Carl Ebel - South Ripley High School, Versailles
- 1968 - Robert Wray - South Side High School, Fort Wayne
- 1967 - Myrtle Burns - Thomas Jefferson Elementary School, South Bend, and Lincoln Elementary School, LaPorte