On January 4th, we held a press conference to debut Super 46 Sandwiches, our homage to Super Bowl XLVI to be played here in Indianapolis this Sunday (February 5th). We worked with Indianapolis Monthly Magazine to put together this great list of 46 of the best sandwiches throughout Indiana. From Fair Oaks to Evansville, from Indianapolis to Roanoke, these 46 sandwiches represent the best of Indiana.
For the past four weeks YOU have been voting on your favorite sandwiches. First, we took the list down from 46 to just 16. From there, the sandwiches were seeded and we began the Super 46 Sandwiches Playoffs. We went from the Sweet 16, down to the Elite Eight, to the Final Four and the Super Bowl of the Super 46 Sandwiches and after more than 250,000 votes we finally have a winner.
Congratulations to:
The Bratwurst | Schnitzelbank (Jasper)
See the Glockenspiel tower and feel at home in the dark Bavarianesque bar in this town founded by German immigrants. Order the bratwurst for two seasoned pork links with zesty mustard on fresh rye bread, with sides of house made German Fries and coleslaw. Add a Hacker-Pshorr Weisse Bier from the tap, and visit the salad bar for famous turnip kraut, herring, homemade soups, and bread with apple butter. Check out the beer steins on your way out.
Bratwurst | Schnitzelbank (Jasper) on Super46.com
Click through to see the results from each round of brackets (in no particular order):
Savory Sixteen:
- Buddy’s Shrimp Roll | The Barking Dog Café
- Bratwurst – Schnitzelbank
- Pot Roast Sandwich – Hobnob Corner Restaurant
- Hamburger – Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop
- Ultimate Grilled Tenderloin – The Streamliner Family Restaurant
- Boogie Monster – Boogie Burger
- Roast Pork Po’ Boy – Papa Roux
- Reuben – Shapiro’s Delicatessen
- Duane Purvis All-American Burger – Triple XXX Family Restaurant
- Prime Rib Sandwich – Harry & Izzy’s
- Breaded Tenderloin – Nickel Plate Bar & Grill
- Meatball Sub – The Historic Steer-In
- Beef Tongue Cheese Steak – The Local Eatery & Pub
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich – Fair Oaks Farms
- Mile High Club – Rock Cola 50s Café
- Double Cheeseburger – The Working Man’s Friend
Appetizing Eight:
- Bratwurst – Schnitzelbank
- Hamburger – Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop
- Ultimate Grilled Tenderloin – The Streamliner Family Restaurant
- Roast Pork Po’ Boy – Papa Roux
- Duane Purvis All-American Burger – Triple XXX Family Restaurant
- Breaded Tenderloin – Nickel Plate Bar & Grill
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich – Fair Oaks Farms
- Mile High Club – Rock Cola 50s Café
Fantastic Four:
- Bratwurst – Schnitzelbank
- Roast Pork Po’ Boy – Papa Roux
- Duane Purvis All-American Burger – Triple XXX Family Restaurant
- Mile High Club – Rock Cola 50s Café
Super 46 Bowl Championship Round:
Congratulations to ALL 46 sandwiches (check out all of them here). While only a handful made it to the final rounds of voting, every single sandwich is fantastic and worth trying. If you’ve decided to try all 46 sandwiches, let us know in the comments below or on our Facebook page.
Find out more information about Super 46 Sandwiches, including pictures of each sandwich and details about each of the restaurants at Super46.com. Super 46 Sandwiches is brought to you by the Indiana Office of Tourism Development and the Publishers of Indianapolis Monthly Magazine.


Follow us: