Best Indiana Pie

Mmmmm, you can almost smell and taste the pies just looking at them. The public has voted, and we’re busy counting. Check back on Monday afternoon to see which pies are Your Ten Favorite.

The Nominees

Rhubarb Pie

Business:
A Piece of Cake
City/Town:
Greenwood
Url:
Read more

Mini Peanut Butter Pie

Business:
Abe Martin Lodge at Brown County State Park
City/Town:
Nashville
Url:
Read more

Heritage Caramel Apple Pie

Business:
Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery
City/Town:
Columbus
Url:
Read more

Strawberry Pizza

Business:
Almost Home
City/Town:
Greencastle
Url:
Read more

Shoo-fly or Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Amish Acres
City/Town:
Nappanee
Url:
Read more

Apple Pie a la mode

Business:
Apple Hill Orchard
City/Town:
Bruceville
Url:
Read more

Cranberry Apple

Business:
Blue River Cafe
City/Town:
Milltown
Url:
Read more

Harvest Moon Pie

Business:
Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery
City/Town:
Danville
Url:
Read more

Sugar Cream Pie

Business:
Clifty Inn at Clifty Falls State Park
City/Town:
Madison
Url:
Read more

Dutch Apple or Shoestring Apple Pie

Business:
Country Lane Bakery
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more

Apple Pie

Business:
County Line Orchard
City/Town:
Hobart
Url:
Read more

Berry Pie

Business:
Das Dutchman Essenhaus
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more

Dutch Apple Pie

Business:
Fat & Sassy
City/Town:
Huntingburg
Url:
Read more

Pecan Pie

Business:
Fort Harrison State Park Inn
City/Town:
Indianapolis
Url:
Read more

Apple Pie

Business:
Grandma’s Pantry
City/Town:
Wakarusa
Url:
Read more

Coconut Cream Pie

Business:
Harvest Moon Bed & Breakfast
City/Town:
Ferdinand
Url:
Read more

Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Huber's Orchard, Winery & Vineyards
City/Town:
Starlight
Url:
Read more

Chocolate Caramel Pecan Pie

Business:
Lisa's Pie Shop
City/Town:
Atlanta
Url:
Read more

Apple, Pumpkin or Toffee Pie

Business:
Marilyn's Bakery
City/Town:
Hobart
Url:
Read more

Dutch Apple Pie

Business:
My Sugar Pie
City/Town:
Zionsville
Url:
Read more

Apple Pie

Business:
Nappanee Bakery & Treat Shoppe
City/Town:
Nappanee
Url:
Read more

Peanut Butter Pie

Business:
Olde Richmond Inn
City/Town:
Richmond
Url:
Read more

Homemade Fruit Pie

Business:
Overlook Restaurant
City/Town:
Leavenworth
Url:
Read more

Pink Lemonade Pie

Business:
Potawatomi Inn at Pokagon State Park
City/Town:
Angola
Url:
Read more

Apple Strudel

Business:
Schnitzelbank
City/Town:
Jasper
Url:
Read more

Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Schwartz Family Restaurant
City/Town:
Eckerty
Url:
Read more

Corn Meal Pie

Business:
Spring Mill Inn at Spring Mill State Park
City/Town:
Mitchell
Url:
Read more

Praline Pumpkin Torte

Business:
Stephenson's General Store
City/Town:
Leavenworth
Url:
Read more

Variety of Cobblers

Business:
Stone Hearth Cafe
City/Town:
Centerville
Url:
Read more

Apple Pie

Business:
The Apple Works
City/Town:
Trafalgar
Url:
Read more

Coconut Cream Pie

Business:
Van's Country Table
City/Town:
Marengo
Url:
Read more

Sour Cream Blueberry Pie

Business:
Village Inn Restaurant
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more

Sugar Cream Pie

Business:
Wick's Pie
City/Town:
Winchester
Url:
Read more