Best Indiana Pie

Our official state pie is Sugar Cream, but we want to know which is your favorite. Check out all the nominees below and then go on a taste-testing adventure! Vote for up to five of your favorite pies. Check back on October 15 to see which make Your Ten Favorite!

The Nominees

Rhubarb Pie

Business:
A Piece of Cake
City/Town:
Greenwood
Url:
Read more
Vote

Mini Peanut Butter Pie

Business:
Abe Martin Lodge at Brown County State Park
City/Town:
Nashville
Url:
Read more
Vote

Heritage Caramel Apple Pie

Business:
Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery
City/Town:
Columbus
Url:
Read more
Vote

Strawberry Pizza

Business:
Almost Home
City/Town:
Greencastle
Url:
Read more
Vote

Shoo-fly or Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Amish Acres
City/Town:
Nappanee
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Pie a la mode

Business:
Apple Hill Orchard
City/Town:
Bruceville
Url:
Read more
Vote

Cranberry Apple

Business:
Blue River Cafe
City/Town:
Milltown
Url:
Read more
Vote

Harvest Moon Pie

Business:
Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery
City/Town:
Danville
Url:
Read more
Vote

Sugar Cream Pie

Business:
Clifty Inn at Clifty Falls State Park
City/Town:
Madison
Url:
Read more
Vote

Dutch Apple or Shoestring Apple Pie

Business:
Country Lane Bakery
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Pie

Business:
County Line Orchard
City/Town:
Hobart
Url:
Read more
Vote

Berry Pie

Business:
Das Dutchman Essenhaus
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more
Vote

Dutch Apple Pie

Business:
Fat & Sassy
City/Town:
Huntingburg
Url:
Read more
Vote

Pecan Pie

Business:
Fort Harrison State Park Inn
City/Town:
Indianapolis
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Pie

Business:
Grandma’s Pantry
City/Town:
Wakarusa
Url:
Read more
Vote

Coconut Cream Pie

Business:
Harvest Moon Bed & Breakfast
City/Town:
Ferdinand
Url:
Read more
Vote

Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Huber's Orchard, Winery & Vineyards
City/Town:
Starlight
Url:
Read more
Vote

Chocolate Caramel Pecan Pie

Business:
Lisa's Pie Shop
City/Town:
Atlanta
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple, Pumpkin or Toffee Pie

Business:
Marilyn's Bakery
City/Town:
Hobart
Url:
Read more
Vote

Dutch Apple Pie

Business:
My Sugar Pie
City/Town:
Zionsville
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Pie

Business:
Nappanee Bakery & Treat Shoppe
City/Town:
Nappanee
Url:
Read more
Vote

Peanut Butter Pie

Business:
Olde Richmond Inn
City/Town:
Richmond
Url:
Read more
Vote

Homemade Fruit Pie

Business:
Overlook Restaurant
City/Town:
Leavenworth
Url:
Read more
Vote

Pink Lemonade Pie

Business:
Potawatomi Inn at Pokagon State Park
City/Town:
Angola
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Strudel

Business:
Schnitzelbank
City/Town:
Jasper
Url:
Read more
Vote

Pumpkin Pie

Business:
Schwartz Family Restaurant
City/Town:
Eckerty
Url:
Read more
Vote

Corn Meal Pie

Business:
Spring Mill Inn at Spring Mill State Park
City/Town:
Mitchell
Url:
Read more
Vote

Praline Pumpkin Torte

Business:
Stephenson's General Store
City/Town:
Leavenworth
Url:
Read more
Vote

Variety of Cobblers

Business:
Stone Hearth Cafe
City/Town:
Centerville
Url:
Read more
Vote

Apple Pie

Business:
The Apple Works
City/Town:
Trafalgar
Url:
Read more
Vote

Coconut Cream Pie

Business:
Van's Country Table
City/Town:
Marengo
Url:
Read more
Vote

Sour Cream Blueberry Pie

Business:
Village Inn Restaurant
City/Town:
Middlebury
Url:
Read more
Vote

Sugar Cream Pie

Business:
Wick's Pie
City/Town:
Winchester
Url:
Read more
Vote