Table of Contents

APPENDIX E

Assessment of Immunization
Coverage Levels in Indiana – 1999

Aaron Kalinowski, MPH
ISDH Immunization Program

Background: The most recent National Immunization Survey found that 74% of 19-35 month old children in Indiana were complete for the basic immunization series, well below the national goal of 90% coverage set by the Healthy People 2000/2010 initiative. Although vaccine-preventable disease incidence rates are at an all-time low, these sub-optimal immunization coverage levels highlight the fact that providers and parents are failing to recognize the importance of completing the immunization series by the child’s second birthday. By conducting immunization assessments among both public and private health care providers throughout Indiana, the ISDH Immunization Program is working with providers to improve immunization coverage levels throughout the state.

Current status of immunization assessments in Indiana: Among health care providers, assessments of the coverage levels of children aged 24-35 months have been completed in local health departments, non-health department public providers, and a sample of private providers enrolled in the Vaccines for Children program. Assessments among private providers began in 1998, while assessments among public providers has been completed annually since 1994. Other assessments completed annually in Indiana include the school, daycare, and Head Start immunization assessments, and the public university immunization assessment.

Public Provider Immunization Assessments: Public clinic assessments have been completed throughout Indiana on an annual basis since 1994. Immunization coverage levels for the 94 local health departments and a majority of the non-health department public providers administering vaccine were assessed in 1999 using CASA, special assessment software designed by the CDC. Among local health departments using the ImTIME immunization tracking software, the entire population of active patients aged 24-35 months was determined. For those health departments and non-health department public providers not using ImTIME, the immunization records of a statistically significant sample of two-year old patients were entered into the software. From this data, reports were generated showing each provider’s immunization coverage levels. In 1999, the median coverage level for the 4:3:1:3 series (4 DTaP, 3 Polio, 1 MMR, and 3 Hib vaccines by 24 months of age) was 85% among local health departments and 67% among non-health department public providers. Coverage levels for the 4:3:1:3 series for local health departments from 1997 – 1999 are shown in Table 1. Median coverage levels from the 1999 public provider assessments, both for individual vaccines and the various immunization series are shown in Table 2. These results demonstrate an overall increase in coverage levels among the local health departments in recent years.

Table 1.
Coverage levels for children 24 months of age,
4:3:1:3 immunization series, local health departments,
Indiana, 1997 – 1999 annual immunization assessments.

Local Health
Department

1997
Coverage
Level %

1998
Coverage
Level %

1999
Coverage
Level %

Adams County Health Department

93.0

59.8

42.9

Allen County Health Department

50.5

67.5

58.6

Bartholomew County Health Department

84.0

89.1

86.1

Benton County Health Department

59.8

59.8

74.0

Blackford County Health Department

83.5

77.2

81.1

Boone County Health Department

78.5

78.2

88.7

Brown County Health Department

55.1

90.2

89.2

Carroll County Health Department

88.4

91.6

92.2

Cass County Health Department

84.3

99.3

85.1

Clark County Health Department

31.3

30.0

80.9

Clay County Health Department

70.7

75.4

73.2

Clinton County Health Department

62.6

64.3

80.2

Crawford County Health Department

68.3

90.5

100.0

Daviess County Health Department

47.0

47.0

87.3

Dearborn County Health Department

86.2

80.6

76.1

Decatur County Health Department

87.9

92.9

91.1

DeKalb County Health Department

25.8

48.4

76.2

Delaware County Health Department

88.9

90.1

84.6

Dubois County Health Department

88.5

91.1

91.5

East Chicago City Health Department

27.6

29.0

61.3

Elkhart County Health Department

73.3

81.6

85.3

Fayette County Health Department

88.6

95.3

93.0

Floyd County Health Department

76.8

80.4

72.4

Fountain-Warren County Health Department

82.0

88.9

81.7

Franklin County Health Department

77.6

53.2

81.3

Fulton County Health Department

80.5

81.5

86.1

Gary City Health Department

33.5

33.8

54.9

Gibson County Health Department

82.3

84.1

76.8

Grant County Health Department

79.6

96.9

100.0

Greene County Health Department

80.6

80.0

89.0

Hamilton County Health Department

94.5

94.7

93.2

Hammond City Health Department

20.9

48.7

65.8

Hancock County Health Department

92.7

90.0

84.5

Harrison County Health Department

89.9

97.8

97.0

Hendricks County Health Department

88.8

92.5

87.9

Henry County Health Department

88.5

88.1

92.1

Howard County Health Department

87.0

77.5

88.5

Huntington County Health Department

67.6

92.8

79.6

Jackson County Health Department

80.3

90.5

91.7

Jasper County Health Department

90.2

92.3

96.2

Jay County Health Department

82.7

83.2

83.7

Jefferson County Health Department

86.4

91.2

85.2

Jennings County Health Department

76.3

76.1

87.6

Johnson County Health Department

90.2

91.5

95.7

Knox County Health Department

81.7

91.2

89.1

Kosciusko County Health Department

77.7

92.6

95.2

LaGrange County Health Department

38.6

80.9

77.1

Lake County Health Department

57.2

68.8

73.6

LaPorte County Health Department

47.2

51.2

72.9

Lawrence County Health Department

86.3

94.4

95.5

Madison County Health Department

83.4

87.7

84.3

Marion County Health Department

65.0

63.7

59.8

Marshall County Health Department

80.8

83.3

85.3

Martin County Health Department

64.6

62.3

68.1

Miami County Health Department

76.0

81.9

84.1

Monroe County Health Department

38.8

87.7

84.5

Montgomery County Health Department

88.0

82.8

83.3

Morgan County Health Department

84.6

80.1

90.8

Newton County Health Department

60.4

89.0

90.5

Noble County Health Department

27.7

59.0

81.0

Ohio County Health Department

79.0

71.8

83.3

Orange County Health Department

40.0

55.6

94.4

Owen County Health Department

50.0

61.7

61.4

Parke County Health Department

51.1

69.9

74.6

Perry County Health Department

89.0

90.2

94.3

Pike County Health Department

62.5

87.8

92.1

Porter County Health Department

77.8

79.0

85.2

Posey County Health Department

51.7

62.1

47.1

Pulaski County Health Department

64.8

82.9

58.3

Putnam County Health Department

83.5

83.7

53.8

Randolph County Health Department

88.0

92.2

91.9

Ripley County Health Department

90.4

76.2

85.6

Rush County Health Department

96.3

93.4

91.1

Scott County Health Department

67.7

70.8

73.7

Shelby County Health Department

90.1

90.0

89.7

Spencer County Health Department

84.8

91.2

98.6

St. Joseph County Health Department

34.6

52.4

49.9

Starke County Health Department

65.6

76.0

62.9

Steuben County Health Department

58.7

66.8

70.3

Sullivan County Health Department

47.0

55.8

50.5

Switzerland County Health Department

80.4

85.7

89.2

Tippecanoe County Health Department

83.0

86.6

97.7

Tipton County Health Department

96.7

99.3

100.0

Union County Health Department

85.2

90.9

92.3

Vanderburgh County Health Department

25.0

37.4

58.1

Vermillion County Health Department

50.5

55.6

58.8

Vigo County Health Department

84.0

84.3

85.2

Wabash County Health Department

70.6

74.8

79.8

Warrick County Health Department

57.0

52.8

96.1

Washington County Health Department

78.6

85.3

81.7

Wayne County Health Department

59.8

26.7

68.3

Wells County Health Department

93.2

97.2

92.9

White County Health Department

79.2

67.4

77.3

Whitley County Health Department

83.5

80.8

90.2

STATE (median)

79.1

81.8

84.9

 

Table 2.
Median immunization coverage levels, local health departments
and non-health department public providers,
Indiana, 1999.

Vaccine or
immunization series

Local health
departments (n=94)

Non-health
department public
providers (n=46)

Individual vaccine

3 DTaP (Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis)

 

97 %*

 

95 %

4 DTaP (Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis)

86 %

71 %

3 Polio (Oral and Inactivated)

95 %

88 %

1 MMR (Measles, Mumps, Rubella)

93 %

82 %

3 Hib (Haemophilus influenzae type b)

95 %

92 %

3 HepB (Hepatitis B)

93 %

87 %

Immunization series

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR

 

86 %*

 

71 %

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR: 3 Hib

85 %

67 %

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR: 3 Hib: 3 HepB

82 %*

74 %

* Does not include data from Marion County Health Department.

Private Provider Immunization Assessments:  Private provider immunization assessments have been completed in Indiana since 1998. The vast majority of private providers included in these assessments are enrolled in the Vaccines for Children Program (VFC), which provides free vaccine to eligible children. In 1998, 112 assessments were completed for private providers throughout the state. In 1999 this number nearly doubled with 215 assessments were completed among private providers. Median coverage levels from the 1998 – 1999 private provider assessments, both for individual vaccines and the various immunization series are shown in Table 3. As can be seen in Table 3, the median 4:3:1:3 coverage level for private providers increased from 50.0% in 1998 to 55.7% in 1999. Despite these increases, coverage levels among VFC-enrolled private providers in Indiana still fall well below the goal of 90% coverage levels among two-year old children in Indiana.

Table 3.
Median immunization coverage levels, by antigen
and immunization series, VFC-enrolled private providers,
Indiana, 1998 and 1999.

Vaccine or
immunization series

1998 median
coverage levels
(n=112)

1999 median
coverage levels
(n=215)

Individual vaccine

3 DTaP (Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis)

 

84 %

 

86 %

4 DTaP (Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis)

51 %

63 %

3 Polio (Oral and Inactivated)

77 %

76 %

1 MMR (Measles, Mumps, and Rubella)

71 %

73 %

3 Hib (Haemophilus influenzae type b)

73 %

83 %

3 HepB (Hepatitis B)

72 %

77 %

Immunization series

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR

 

50 %

 

57 %

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR: 3 Hib

50 %

56 %

4 DTaP: 3 Polio: 1 MMR: 3 Hib: 3 HepB

44 %

50 %

School immunization assessment: All schools in Indiana are required to submit reports detailing the immunization coverage levels for pre-kindergarten, kindergarten, first grade, sixth grade, and new entering students. In the 1999-2000 school year new legislation became effective which required 3 doses of hepatitis B vaccine for all kindergarten and first grade students. Additionally, new rules became effective which standardized the school immunization requirements with the ACIP immunization schedule. In previous years, kindergarten immunization coverage levels have remained constant at 97%. However, this number dropped in the 1999-2000 school year to 81% (Table 4). Now that school administrators and nurses have had a full year to become familiar with and fully implement new school immunization requirements, coverage levels are expected to return to their high rates in the coming school year.

Table 4.
School immunization coverage levels among Indiana kindergarten students,
1995-96 to 1999-2000 school years.

 

Public Schools

Private Schools

All Schools

School
Year

# reporting
sites

%
complete

# reporting
sites

%
complete

# reporting
sites

%
complete

1995-1996

1,789

97 %

472

97 %

2,261

97 %

1996-1997

1,846

97 %

553

98 %

2,399

97 %

1997-1998

1,822

97 %

492

98 %

2,314

97 %

1998-1999

1,844

97 %

466

98 %

2,310

97 %

1999-2000

1,840

80 %

474

89 %

2,314

81 %

Daycare and Head Start center immunization assessments: All daycare and Head Start centers in Indiana are also required to submit annual immunization reports to ISDH. These reports reflect the age-appropriate immunization coverage levels of children who attend these facilities. Despite the fact that no changes were made to the daycare and Head Start immunization requirements in 1999, statewide immunization coverage levels of children attending these facilities fell compared to previous years’ levels (Table 5).

Table 5.
Daycare and Head Start immunization coverage levels
among children attending these facilities,
1995-96 to 1999-2000 school years.

  

Daycare Centers

Head Start Centers

School
Year

# reporting
sites

%
complete

# reporting
sites

%
complete

1995-1996

460

90 %

152

88 %

1996-1997

498

90 %

152

91 %

1997-1998

462

91 %

139

91 %

1998-1999

398

91 %

142

90 %

1999-2000

426

85 %

161

85 %

University immunization assessments: On an annual basis six universities in Indiana (Ball State University, Indiana State University, Indiana University, Purdue University, the University of Southern Indiana, and Vincennes University) are required to submit immunization reports indicating the immune status of their matriculating students. These students are required to provide documented proof of immunity to measles, mumps, rubella, tetanus, and diphtheria prior to their matriculation. If students do not provide the proper documentation of immunity, they are to be denied second semester enrollment. Through improved enforcement of these requirements, immunization coverage levels have steadily increased, as a whole, among these six universities (Tables 6 and 7).

Table 6.
Vaccination coverage levels, by vaccine, among matriculating students
at the six universities required to report to the Indiana State Department of Health,
1995-96 to 1999-2000 school years.

School year

Measles

Mumps

Rubella

Tetanus/Diphtheria

1995-96

83 %

87 %

88 %

88 %

1996-97

85 %

88 %

88 %

88 %

1997-98

86 %

89 %

89 %

89 %

1998-99

86 %

88 %

88 %

88 %

1999-2000

90 %

92 %

92 %

92 %

Table 7.
Percent of university students completely vaccinated,
1999-2000 school year.

University

Students
Covered

Measles

Mumps

Rubella

Tetanus/
Diphtheria

Ball State University

4,825

76 %

75 %

75 %

75 %

Indiana State University

2,270

97 %

99 %

99 %

98 %

Indiana University – Bloomington

9,492

88 %

90 %

90 %

91 %

Purdue University – West Lafayette

8,927

96 %

97 %

98 %

98 %

University of Southern Indiana

3,140

100 %

100 %

100 %

100 %

Vincennes University

2,208

93 %

93 %

93 %

93 %

TOTALS

30,862

90 %

92 %

92 %

92 %

Table of Contents

[an error occurred while processing this directive]